IF election cheating happened in the 2022 presidential elections, where were the pieces of evidence to back that claim?
According to telecommunications expert turned whistleblower Eliseo Rio Jr., a former Cabinet member of the Duterte administration, the answer lies on the data, which the Commission on Elections (Comelec) has uploaded on its website on March 23, 2023, or ten months after the May 9 elections held the previous year.
According to Rio, Comelec chair George Garcia billed the uploaded data as “transmission logs,” but they turned out to be “reception logs,” that contained a list of data from vote counting machines (VCMs) received on the night of May 9, 2022, or the election day.
Rio said his group of election analysts immediately questioned the starting time indicated in those reception logs because it was improbable that these VCMs received election results (ERrs) at 19:08:50 (7:08:50 pm) on the night of May 9. According to Rio, even the Comelec General Instructions required nine major tasks to accomplish before any VCM transmission.
According to Rio, before any transmission could be made, it could take at least 19 minutes after voting closed at 7 pm. “The earliest time that VVCM transmissions can be received by the Transparency Server would be at 7:19 pm, not 7:08 pm, Rio said.
Rio went to discuss the counting process, which occurred after the closing of the voting at 7 pm. He said: first, it took one minute to print one copy of the National Election Result (ER) and the required printing of eight copies would take eight minutes; second, one copy of the local ER took 30 second to print and the required printing of eight copies would take four minutes; third since the other major tasks took around seven minutes to perform, the total time from closing the voting to the ER transmission would take 19 minutes.
Rio concluded: “The earliest time that the Transparency Server would be receivingf VCM transmission would be at 7:19 pm, not 7:08 pm, as indicated in the Reception Logs shown by Comelec on March 23, 2023.”
Rio cited instances, which showed anomalies in the Comelec uploaded data. He surmised that prepared data were stored in unidentified sites in between the VCMs, which transmitted the votes, or ERs, to the Transparency Server, the final destiny of the ERs. In between the VCMs and the Transparency Server, manipulation of election results happened, he surmised.
Rio, who was once the DICT secretary, surmised these unidentified sites could have transmitted the manipulated votes at an earlier stipulated time to the Transparency. The disparity in time of transmission and reception were details that could not be ignored, Rio said.
The F. De Mesa Elementary School, a voting center in Barangay Putatan in Muntinlupa City, had 727 registered voters, of whom 591 voters actually voted. The ER was printed at 20:27:01 of May 9, 2022. The Transparency Server received the ER at 19:47:37 on Mayo 9, 2022. It appeared the Transparency Server received the ER 39 minutes, 24 seconds ahead of the actual printing. How it happened was something that boggled the mind.
The same thing happened to the VCM in Barangay San Andres in the town of Victoria in Tarlac. The voting center in San Andres Elementary School had 799 registered voters, of whom at 681 went to vote. The ER was printed at 22:03:39 on May 9, 2022. The Transparency Server received the ER at exactly 20:04:20. It was surprising that the reception was ahead by one hour, 19 seconds to the printing of ER.
In Barangay San Nicolas in the town of Castillejos, Zambales, a voting center in San Nicolas Elementary School had 507 voters, who went to the polls out of 712 registered voters. The ER was printed at 19:52:28 of Mayo 9, 2022. But the Transparency Server received it at 19:20:58 of the same night. The reception was ahead of 31 minuto, 30 seconds before the printing.
The same thing happened in a voting center in Monterey Hills Clubhouse in Barangay Silanganan in the town of San Mateo in the province of Rizal. The ER was printed at 23:33:20 of May 9, 2022. The surprising thing was that the Transparency Server rec eived the ER at 23:10:12 of May 9, 2022. The reception was ahead by 23 minutes, 8 seconds before the ER printing.
The official data from VCM in Barangay Paing in the town of Bantay in Ilocos Sur had the same character. The number of registered voters was 459 in Paing Day Care Center voting center, of whom 408 voted. The ER was printed at 19:18.27 on Mayo, 9, 2022, but the Comelec reception log said the ER was received by the Transparency Server at 19:11:21 of Mayo 9, 2022. The reception was ahead by 7 minutes, 26 seconds before the ER printing.
The data from Barangay Tayac sa Bantay, Ilocos Sur was equally surprising. The six polling precincts in Tayac Elementary school showed the ER was printed at 20:34:15 on Mayo 9, 2022. Baut the reception log said the Transparency Server received the ER at 19:24;45 on May 9, 2022. It could not be explained why the transmission happened ahead by one hour, 9 minutes , 20 seconds before the ER printing.
According to Rio, the Comelec has a lot to explain in the disparity of the time of printing and transmission. Reception of transmitted Ers should not come earlier than the time of printing. But the Comelec haa chosen to be quiet.
Rio said in a statement:
“The Raw Files uploaded in the COMELEC website show that there were more than 2,000 VCMs in the National Capital Region (NCR) with exactly the same Private IP Address - 192.168.0.2. This is technicallly IMPOSSIBLE when using only one network!
Private IP Address, are clear proofs that there was a
secret and illegal Private Network that first collected ALL Election Returns
(ER) BEFORE these were transmitted to the COMELEC Servers.
“And this Private Network “in the Middle” was kept hidden to the public because it does not conform with the legal End-to-End Transmission Path that was demonstrated to stakeholders on March 22, 2022. Its existence was made known only when COMELEC published, inadvertently or purposely, the Raw Files in their website, on March 23, 2023.
“All VCMs used in the 2022 transmitted their ERs DIRECTLY to this illegal Private Network “in the Middle” which was secretly created by COMELEC/Smartmatic.
“This explains so many things why COMELEC is stonewalling the numerous questions of irregularities observed in the 2022 Elections, such as 1) showing proof that the Transmission Logs of the Telcos thru their Call Detail Records (CDR) can show that there really VCM transmissions that passed their public networks in the first hour after voting closed, to account for that unbelievable 20M+ votes shown to the public at 8:02pm of May9, 2022; 2) how the Transparency Server was receiving ERs when these were NOT YET transmitted by the VCMs; 3) the ones manipulating this illegal Private Network seem to know what the official results of the 2022 Elections will be even BEFORE counting of votes began; 4) why Chairman George Garcia could not fulfill his commitment to show the Transmission Logs of the Telcos; 5) why the Reception logs showed a start time of 7:08pm when VCM transmissions can only start at 7:19pm at the earliest because of the 9 major tasks required by the COMELEC General Instructions BEFORE any transmissions can be made; and 6) why by 9pm of May 9, 2022 “TAPOS NA ANG BOKSING” as far as to who won as President and VP.
“COMELEC must show to the public the exact schematic diagram of this Private Network “in the Middle”and explain 1) how the IP Addresses of the Telcos/ISPs were translated from Public to Private; 2) how was this procured and at what cost; 3) who was its Network Administrator and 4) why this illegal Private Network ‘in the Middle’ was made in the first place.”
No comments:
Post a Comment